Clash of Titans: Porsche 911 S/T vs Toyota GR Yaris

image
Clash of Titans: Porsche 911 S/T vs Toyota GR Yaris - Image for illustration purposes only
12-23-2024topgear

A Duel in the Manual Realm

Two automotive icons—each with a manual gearbox—are battling for the crown. The Porsche 911 S/T, a pinnacle GT car, and the Toyota GR Yaris, a rally car for the road, are here to challenge perceptions and deliver thrills.

Porsche 911 S/T: Celebrating 60 Years

With only 1,963 units, the Porsche 911 S/T is a diamond in the rough.
- Engine & Weight: 518bhp 4.0-liter flat-six engine, 1,380kg.
- Transmission: Six-speed manual with short throws and reduced-weight components.
- Drive Experience: No rear-wheel steering, pure driving dynamics, blistering performance with a 9,000rpm redline.
- Market Buzz: Prices are already soaring beyond its base of £231,600.

Toyota GR Yaris: The Rally Champion

Initially a budget darling, the GR Yaris has evolved.
- Price & Updates: Now starts at £44,250, featuring substantial updates from motorsport insights.
- Performance Upgrades: 1.6-liter turbo three-cylinder with 276bhp, strengthened chassis, redesigned interior.
- Driving Dynamics: Agile, adjustable torque distribution with GR-FOUR modes, sharp handling.

Manual Transmission: The Heart and Soul

Both cars feature six-speed manuals that inject excitement into every drive. While the Porsche demands finesse with its lightweight clutch, Toyota offers an eight-speed auto option but excels with its manual spirit.

Driving Modes: Tailor Your Thrills

- 911 S/T: Focused on precision, balance, and sensory feedback.
- GR Yaris: Three drive modes with a GR-FOUR knob for flexible power distribution, offering both control and playful oversteer.

Unleashing the Beast

The Porsche Phenomenon

- Performance: 0–62mph in 3.7 seconds, top speed of 186mph.
- Experience: Direct steering, balanced handling, and a thrill-inducing high-revving engine.

Yaris: A Spirited Fighter

- Performance: 0–62mph in 5.2 seconds.
- Experience: Maintains its playful character with improved aggression and responsiveness.

A Tailored Legacy

The 911 S/T and GR Yaris embody the passion for manuals, offering diverse yet equally engaging experiences. Both cars amplify their manufacturer's dedication to crafting timeless manual driving experiences.

  

Summary: The Porsche 911 S/T and Toyota GR Yaris, though diverse, embody the joy of manual driving. While the 911 S/T represents Porsche's ultimate GT engineering, the GR Yaris channels rally excitement into everyday roads. Each car showcases the enduring allure and thrill of the manual gearbox in modern automotive design.

What Others Are Saying...


theo
Interesting comparison. Both cars have their strengths, though the price difference is quite staggering. That said, driving dynamics are what really matter.

nova03
I’m curious if the hype will match performance in real-world driving. Marketing often oversells these cars. Let's see how they perform when put to the test.